Dems Rips ‘MAGA’ Supreme Court After 9-0 Vote on EPA Waters Rule

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., slammed the Supreme Court’s ruling Thursday that limited the Environmental Protection Agency’s ability to regulate bodies of water, calling it a “MAGA” court even though the decision was 9-0.

On Thursday, the high court issued an opinion that narrowed the EPA’s broad definition of Waters of the United States (WOTUS). The court said the federal government must define WOTUS as a water source with a “continuous surface connection” to major bodies of water.

The decision upended an attempt by the Biden administration to regulate wetlands, lakes, ponds, streams and other “relatively permanent” waterways, which had relied on a broad reading of the EPA’s authority under the Clean Water Act (CWA).

“This MAGA Supreme Court is continuing to erode our country’s environmental laws,” Schumer tweeted after the opinion was released. “Make no mistake – this ruling will mean more polluted water, and more destruction of wetlands.”

The ruling came down 9-0 in favor of plaintiffs Michael and Chantell Sackett, two Idaho residents whom the EPA prohibited from building a home near a wetland years ago.

“The EPA ordered the Sacketts to restore the site, threatening penalties of over $40,000 per day,” Alito’s majority opinion stated. “The EPA classified the wetlands on the Sacketts’ lot as ‘waters of the United States’ because they were near a ditch that fed into a creek, which fed into Priest Lake, a navigable, intrastate lake. The Sacketts sued, alleging that their property was not ‘waters of the United States.’

However, the court split 5-4 in its analysis of how the federal government should define a water source under the Clean Air Act.

“Understanding the CWA to apply to wetlands that are distinguishable from otherwise covered ‘waters of the United States’ would substantially broaden [existing statute] to define ‘navigable waters’ as ‘waters of the United States and adjacent wetlands,’” Alito wrote.

Republicans and industry groups embraced the decision as a blow against what they view as federal overreach and excessive regulation.

“Big win today at the US Supreme Court,” said West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey, whose office led 26 states in filing an amicus brief supporting the Sacketts.

“Earlier this year, in a separate case, we obtained a preliminary injunction of the new Biden Administration WOTUS policy,” Morrisey said. “I will never hold back against federal overreach as we always step up to defend West Virginia jobs, our values, our freedoms, and our Constitution.”

However, the White House said the court’s decision “aims to take our country backwards.”

“It will jeopardize the sources of clean drinking water for farmers, businesses and millions of Americans,” White House press secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said at Thursday’s press briefing in reaction to the decision

President Biden will use every legal authority available to him to ensure Americans in every state have clean water,” she added.

Mod

Related Posts

Devastated Mom Wantss to Adopt, Spots Girl at Adoption Agency Strikingly Similar to Her Late Daughter

After losing her five-year-old daughter to cancer, a grieving mother finally decides to adopt another child. But when a secret held by her estranged husband comes to…

At 44 years old, she weighed 605 pounds and dreamed of losing weight

At 44 years old, she weighed 605 pounds and dreamed of losing weight. But look at how she looks now. 😵😨 By the age of 11, her…

3 Day Old Baby Girl Stuns Everyone After Video Catches Her In The Act!

In an astonishing and heartwarming tale that has taken the world by storm, a newborn baby from Pennsylvania has amazed both her parents and medical professionals by…

My Husband’s Pregnant Secretary Wanted to Take My Mansion — But She Didn’t Know I’d Been Preparing for Their Betrayal All Along

When you’ve built your life from nothing — piece by piece, sacrifice by sacrifice — you don’t just sit there and watch it collapse. No. You prepare….

Blake Shelton And Gwen Stefani Just Dropped a BOMBSHELL Baby Announcement, But Its the BABYS NAME Thats Breaking the Internet! From country charm to No Doubt edge, this babys name is 100% iconic, and totally unexpected!

Country superstar Blake Shelton and pop icon Gwen Stefani have entered a beautiful new chapter: parenthood. The couple joyfully announced the birth of their first child together,…

New law could see killer of Ukrainian refugee face rare execution method

A new law could potentially see the killer of Ukrainian Iryna Zarutska put to death using an extremely rare method of execution. The slaying of Zarutksa, a…

This Post Has 3 Comments

  1. Tell Chucky Schumer and the Democrats to stick it! 9-0 is not a MAGA decision. While we are at it MAGA is for “Make America Great Again” and if that is offending to you leave the country! If you like the crook you votede in to destroy this country then Leave! Read about Socialism and find out it is 0 for 41 attempts! You don’t realise how lucky you are to live in this country!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *